The below table should provide you with a guide for rating the officials of a particular game.
Competent |
Score 10 - Made all calls that they should; Calls made were correct and accurate; Reviewed calls were appropriately close and final ruling was correct. They did their job. |
Adequate |
Score 8 - Missed or incorrectly made a couple of minor calls. Did not miss or make any incorrect calls that could have influenced the game. |
Mediocre |
Score 6 - A few bad calls or non-calls that had limit or no influence on the game. |
Unsatisfactory |
Score 4 - Several bad critical or major calls that influenced the game. Missed serious violations |
Poor |
Score 2 - Missed or ignore serious violation where injury occurred, e.g. defender leading with helmet. Made major bad calls or missed/ignored them. |
Incompetent |
Score 0 - Calls made or not throughout the game were incorrect, appeared bias or just ignored. Challenges were incorrectly resolved. In addition, calls were inconsistent, e.g., late hit were called sometimes and ignored at others. |